30 Lessons from 30 Women: Marilynne Robinson

“For me writing has always felt like praying, even when I wasn’t writing prayers, as I was often enough. You feel that you are with someone…”

“Well, but how deeply I regret any sadness you have suffered and how grateful I am in anticipation of any good you have enjoyed. That is to say, I pray for you. And there’s an intimacy in it.”

-from Gilead by Marilynne Robinson



In April of 2013, I picked up two pregnancy tests from Walgreens and headed home. I paced around our small apartment, which was a very small area in the men’s dorm room we inhabited. Feelings of nervousness and claustrophobia eventually nudged me into the bathroom to take the test. I peed, I waited, and then I stared. Yep. Pregnant.

We hadn’t been planning for a baby, so we were initially shocked. I only guessed I might be pregnant because I was feeling so unlike myself and carrying shooting lower back pain for two weeks. That little positive sign on the stick sent panic through me. And then, my husband wrapped his arms around me and reminded me of what this actually meant. We were having a baby. We were starting our family, the one we’d talked about and hoped for. This was good, as unplanned as it was.

We lived the next three weeks in anticipation. We couldn’t wait for our first appointment to nail down exactly how far along I was. Because it was so early and because I felt pretty clueless on protocol for baby welcoming, we decided to hold onto the news until after our appointment. Those weeks went by fairly normally, except for the fact that I had immediately connected myself to this little one growing inside me.

About three weeks after discovering I was pregnant, I started bleeding a little and feeling poorly. I called my doctor and she assured me it was a part of early pregnancy. If it worsened, though, I was to head to the ER. A few days later, the bleeding had only increased and my fears were overwhelming me. We drove to the ER in silence and tears, hoping desperately that this visit would simply quiet our anxiety. Three hours after we’d checked in, we left deflated and weary. Our baby would not make it through the weekend.

I miscarried at home, in our bed and bathroom, on a Sunday night. The fear and grief that filled that night seem so far off, and I’m thankful for God’s grace in that. But the weeks and months that followed were some of the hardest I’ve faced. My first few days of grieving were strange. I was insecure and vulnerable, so I only shared the news with my family. As I expected, they were amazing in their responses. There was such love and support and truth extended to Reed and I in that time. We felt just a bit lighter in those days because of the way our families helped carry the pain.
The strange part of grief came a couple days after we’d shared with our families. I was on my way to work, riding in the passenger seat because Reed had to use our one car for the day. I was pretty quiet and Reed was trying to be encouraging. He asked me what my mind was doing, how I was feeling about the day, what I hoped to do to rest later. I stared out the window and cried my morning’s regular amount of tears. As he continued, I became angrier. Not at him, but at the idea of working while my baby was gone. At the idea of dealing with end-of-the-year grades and repeatedly asking students to face their computer screen.  I was mad that this was so difficult and draining, and I wanted, more than anything, for everything to stop.

We had just passed the sketchy McDonald’s and the industrial buildings when Reed and I started to argue. He wanted me to take some days off, but I was being characteristically stubborn and shutting everything down. As we went back and forth, I finally screamed, “I SHOULD BE ABLE TO HANDLE THIS!” Through my scream, angry, heavy tears spilled down my face. Reed grabbed my phone, called my boss, and confidently announced that I wouldn’t be coming in today. I slumped down into the seat, tired and secretly thankful.

The rest of the day was an odd, detached blur of shopping and indulging. I needed to distract my brain from all those ping-ponging thoughts. I wandered through the mall at 10 in the morning, buying white pants and staring at bulldog puppies through the cloudy glass. When I finished, I wasn’t ready to face home, so I settled down in the bookstore with coffee and a book. I’d started Gilead by Marilynne Robinson, but I’d barely read 15 pages before that day. As I read my book, there, in the large, impersonal Barnes and Noble, I began to weep as I read these words:

Well, but how deeply I regret any sadness you have suffered and how grateful I am in anticipation of any good you have enjoyed. That is to say, I pray for you. And there’s an intimacy in it.”

Gilead is the story of a dying father writing to his young son. I was the mother writing to, praying for, her unborn child. It had all happened so quickly. The fear, the excitement, the dreams for this little one. And then, things changed very abruptly that night in the hospital. What a crazy roller coaster it was. So as I read those words, I felt understood. My written words were my prayers for the hope that would not be realized. I would never know what this child loved or laughed for. I wouldn’t see this baby walk or celebrate Christmas or play with cousins. Even more than that, though, the realization hit me that I wouldn’t know this little one’s sadness. Something in me attached myself very quickly to the idea of comforter and nurturer. I loved that idea, the picture of God growing me to be more compassionate and patient for this child of mine. I wanted to protect this baby. But I couldn’t.

I did my best to stubbornly avoid any real feelings that day, but God had different plans. That book, those words – that was a pivotal moment in my grieving process. That day I chose to continue praying. I chose to embrace the huge, heavy sadness of this loss and cling to God. I felt like someone knew my pain, even in this fictional, very different account. They knew what it was to love a child, while at the same time losing out on the fullness of the relationship.

Of course, there was more to grieve and more to work through, but at that point, Robinson’s words were enough. The following year was a hard one, and I often returned to that day’s journal entry for encouragement. Writing as prayer, and prayer as intimacy. These are realizations I will carry with me for years to come. I couldn’t be more thankful for the book that came at the most appropriate of times.